Dear Jasper John,
I have to say that you and Jasper O’Connell have a much tougher row to hoe than I do. You two have to square the circle in trying to make laissez-faire capitalism compatible with Christianity. One proclaims ” every man for himself and the devil takes the hindmost” while the other says “whatever you do to the least of these” you do unto me. Your only advantage lies in that yours is a position the SNL Church Lady might have called “conveeenient” and is quite common among those trying to justify their privileges. The Republican party comes to mind.
One question I have for both of you. Why do you call on the vast powers of the “gooferment” to force women to bear children they do not want? On one hand you say any taxation is theft but turn around and say that the government has the absolute power to outlaw abortion. It would seem to me that libertarians would be among the strongest supporters of abortion rights. Rights over your own body seem to trump rights over your money. Money is a creation of the state, so its seems reasonable for the government to have some controls on it. Do you ever think of how draconian a police state we would need to enforce anti-abortion laws?
While on the subject of abortion I have to say that I have always favored policies aimed at reducing the number of abortions via providing health care, shelter, education etc. There is no way I find abortions to be noble. On a personal level my wife and I recently helped a cousin’s girl friend carry an baby to term in very unfortunate circumstances. Do to restrictions put in by local conservative politicians she was denied food for the baby at one point. Guess who had to buy the food instead. I have never seen conservatives at the county offices offering to cover the expenses of mothers with newborn infants.
Sincerely yours,
Donald M Stebbins
BS 1961
# – # – #
[JR:
<1> It's not "every man for himself". Where did you get that idea from? What we are saying is that "YOU" have no right to steal the wealth created by others to "GIVE" to those you feel "NEED" it. If I think some one warrants being helped, I'll help. That's charity. When "YOU" take it, even if you do the same thing. (You won't.) That's THEFT.
<2> I don't know about "Oconnell The Younger", but I don't want the Gooferment to FORCE anybody to do anything. I'd like to see abortion be unnecessary and recognized for the self and societally destructive practice it is. Like human sacrifice, we see in the movies. But I'm unwilling to kill people to stop killing people. Common sense should prevail.
<3> Money is NOT the creation of the State. Tyrants take over money because it's the easiest way to control people. Gold and silver have been money for 4000 years. Long before there was ever a State. We need money to allow the division of labor to make us all prosperous. And, greed does wonders to make humans cooperate. You can't get stuff without those "certificates of appreciation" from your fellow workers. Greed is good.
<4> "Polices reducing the number of abortions" means that we're giving the Gooferment our approval to kill people. I'm no fan of "politicians" of either party. But, now that you bring it up, why is the Gooferment feeding babies? That's the role of family, tribe, clans, churches, fraternities, sororities, and charities. In a civil society, not everything MUST be done by the Gooferment. As a matter of principle, ANYTHING the Gooferment does is, by definition, immoral (i.e., force initiated on people), ineffective (i.e., doesn't accomplish the desired end; unintended consequences) and inefficient (i.e., something done at a cost that is more than if there was a voluntary solution).
<5> By you buying the food, you eliminated a bunch of "handling fees" and put a bunch of bureaucrats out of work. Shame on you. They need their peons to justify their continued employment in "public service".
<6> ATDA! BTW "capitalism", even the not so Lazy Fair here and today, makes for fat poor people. Despite the Gooferment trying to keep all those poor people in servitude to the politicians and bureaucrats. Just a different plantation!
]
<<spread out for ease of readability>>
# – # – # – # – # 2011-Jul-24 @ 14:59